Issue 68 EU and Turkey May 2, 2013

We are not talking about dinner; we are talking about the country known as Turkey. It has applied for membership for the European Union (EU) and wishes to join the rest of the European community. But there are road blocks.

Religious road block: As many know, Turkey is a Muslim Country. Despite it being secular members of the EU like Frances government fear letting Turkey join due to a possible influx of Turkish migrants into their communities. France and Germany particularly are hesitant due to their inability to bring their Muslim populations into the mainstream of their societies. The results are small ghettos with their own micro governments, languages, and culture that are hostile to outsiders. Hate crimes and violence due occur and the governments feel helpless. As a result, they hope to avoid compounding the problem by preventing Turkey from joining. The only problem with that logic is that the opposite may happen. For every new entrant into the EU, its member countries feared an influx of migrants. However, most of these populations actually went home due to their feelings of isolation in the larger European community. What blocks these people from going home is a lack of money and the other legal and financial hurdles of trying to go home. In other words, Turkey joining will provide a chance for these people to find a place to fit in and finally feel at home.

Geographic road block: Another problem also has to due with Islam and its Muslim followers. In this instance it is Turkey’s neighbors. Europeans fear that by allowing Turkey to join, it will open up the rest of Europe to the hostile Middle East and the Jihadist element that exists there. In short, they don't want Iraq as their neighbor. But in truth, Turkey as a bastion of culture and peace would act as a buffer. While many countries in the Middle East are in turmoil, Turkey has a solid foundation and is very powerful militarily. Not many countries would dare mess with the Turks. Also, Turkey and its people can be used to demonstrate how western ideals and Muslim ideals can co-exist. Essentially show that a harmony can be achieved and thus ease the fears of possible future radicals, thus shrinking the potential terrorist threat we all face.

Internal road block: The last obstacle to Turkey joining is human rights issues. At current, Turkey enforces its secular society with force. It has to stop that and fast. Banning the head scarf and other religious garb will only create resentment. Basically let people act and dress how they wish so long as no one is harmed. Turkey can enforce the secular mindset by ensuring people understand they can have religion and let it run their own personal life, but it must never be forced on others.

There is one other internal problem and that is the Kurds. They want a nation of their own and they want it now. This is something I as an American can respect. However, Turkey is now dealing with Kurdish separatists and the result has been terrorism. To compound the issue, the Kurds in Iraq have a section all to themselves and the Kurds in Syria have seized upon the havoc and taken over cities and towns to cement their dream of self rule. Turkey has come to the negotiation table and results look promising, but there is a long struggle ahead and Europe fears another situation like the Israelis and Palestinians. Turkey must find a happy medium with respect to the Kurds who have the power to make or break the Turks and it aspirations.

Conclusions: Turkey I believe should be allowed to join. It is a strong and vibrant country with much to offer to the rest of Europe. The religious and geographic road blocks are easily dismissed if Turkey just provides the right incentives and some really good arguments. On the internal front, the secular enforcement is also changing and Turkey is making head way there as well. It is just the issue with the Kurds that remains. Probably the best solution would be Turkey and the rest of Europe bringing all the Kurds from Iraq and Syria into Turkey and giving them some form of economic and governmental independence. It would be a country within a country if you will. But, these details and how smoothly something like that will go depends on all the actors involved and Turkey can still be allowed to join regardless if the other EU countries make an exception. From here it is up to the Turks to decide if they still wish to join. They must decide through their elections if joining is still worth the effort. So I say to the Turks, use your right to self determination to decide for your selves if it is worth your governments Europe or bust path.